Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Tina Fey

   Portia Nathan

2. 

   Ann Harada

   Mrs. Lafont

3. 

   Ben Levin

   Junior Lafont

4. 

   Dan Levy

   James

5. 

   Maggie Keenan-Bolger

   Girl on Tour

6. 

   Gloria Reuben

   Corinne

7. 

   Paul Rudd

   John Pressman

8. 

   Wallace Shawn

   Clarence

9. 

   Elaine Kussack

   Abby

10. 

    Christopher Evan Welch

    Brandt

11. 

    Michael Genadry

    Ben

12. 

    Juliet Brett

    Praying Applicant

13. 

    John Brodsky

    Smug Kid

14. 

    Camille Branton

    Gymnast

15. 

    Sarita Choudhury

    Rachael

16. 

    Michael Sheen

    Mark

17. 

    Ken Barnett

    Admissions Counselor

18. 

    Nat Wolff

    Jeremiah

19. 

    Travis Bratten

    Quest Student

20. 

    Tanisha Long

    Quest Student

21. 

    Nadia Alexander

    Quest Student

22. 

    Karen Pham

    Quest Student

23. 

    Travaris Spears

    Nelson

24. 

    Lily Tomlin

    Susannah

25. 

    Rob Campbell

    Richard

26. 

    Sonya Walger

    Helen

27. 

    Olek Krupa

    Polokov

28. 

    Roby Sobieski

    Makeout Guy

29. 

    Lauren Schaffel

    Student at Party

30. 

    Brian Charles Johnson

    Student at Party

31. 

    Lipica Shah

    Student at Party

32. 

    Jarod Einsohn

    Keg Guy

33. 

    Caliaf St. Aubyn

    Keg Guy's Friend

34. 

    Zita Geoffroy

    Tour Group Mom

35. 

    Laura Jordan

    Woman

36. 

    Zachary Unger

    Jeremiah - 8 Years Old

37. 

    Lisa Emery

    Mrs. Pressman

38. 

    Mihran Slougian

    Jeremiah's Dad

39. 

    Lynne Taylor

    Jeremiah's Mom

40. 

    Brian d'Arcy James

    Christopher Flynn

41. 

    Leigha Hancock

    Yulia Karasov

42. 

    Sarah Quinn

    Young Mother

43. 

    Jason Blaj

    Supermarket Kid

44. 

    David Simins

    A Capella Singer

45. 

    Brad Wilson

    A Capella Singer

46. 

    Ryan McCarty

    A Capella Singer

47. 

    Krishna Choudhary

    A Capella Singer

48. 

    Ricky Jones

    A Capella Singer

49. 

    Thomas Merckens

    A Capella Singer

50. 

    Alan Robert Southworth

    A Capella Singer

51. 

    Chris Bronwell

    A Capella Singer

52. 

    Chris Palermo

    A Capella Singer

53. 

    Anthony Capers

    Jeremiah's Buddy

54. 

    Julia Faye Fisher

    Agency Receptionist

55. 

    Gameela Wright

    Woman in Adoption Agency

56. 

    James P. Anderson

    Baxter Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)

57. 

    Tina Benko

    Andrea (uncredited)

58. 

    Matthew Broadley

    Twin Brother (uncredited)

59. 

    Vanessa Carter

    Quest Student (uncredited)

60. 

    Alix Cross

    Quest Student (uncredited)

61. 

    Jonathon Culver

    Quest Student (uncredited)

62. 

    Giullian Yao Gioiello

    Princeton Applicant (uncredited)

63. 

    Brandon Lee Harris

    Office Assistant (uncredited)

64. 

    Alice Litvak

    Twin Sister (uncredited)

65. 

    Nicole Maggio

    Lacrosse Girl (uncredited)

66. 

    Alexis Molnar

    Princeton College Applicant (uncredited)

67. 

    Meaghan Monaghan

    Student (uncredited)

68. 

    Rachel Moss

    Lacrosse Player (uncredited)

69. 

    Ismaelpeter Casillas Nelson

    Cow Milking Expert (uncredited)

70. 

    Edward Sass III

    Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)

71. 

    Danielle Senk

    Lacrosse Player (uncredited)

72. 

    Natasha Tax

    Prep School Girl (uncredited)

73. 

    Barbara Vincent

    Birthday Party Guest (uncredited)

74. 

    Joshua Hinck

    Sebastian