Matt Damon

Henry Thomas

Lucas Black

Penélope Cruz

Rubén Blades

Robert Patrick

Julio Oscar Mechoso

Angelina Torres

J.D. Young

Laura Poe

Sam Shepard

Yvette Diaz

Imelda Colindres

Augustin Solis

Elizabeth Ibarra

Miriam Colon

Lonnie Rodriguez

Raul Malo

Fredrick Lopez

Ferron Lucero Jr.

Manuel Sanchez

Denes Lujan

Edwin M. Figueroa

Matthew E. Montoya

Julian Prada

Roberto Enrique Pineda

Vincente Ramos

George R. Lopez

J.D. Garfield

Julio Cesar Cedillo

Marc Miles

Brian Orr

Bruce Dern

Jesse Plemons

Daniel Lanois

Billy Bob Thornton

Ted Tally

Sally Menke

Jimmy Ortega

Norman Howell

Nikoletta Skarlatos

Daniel O'Haco

Melissa V. Barnes

Mike Watson

Lynne K. Eagan

Julie Janes-Love

Dick 'Skip' Evans

Jim Pratt

Fred Murphy

John Brian King

Gianna Sparacino

Pamela Altieri-Paterra

Randy E. Moore

Buddy Van Horn

Richard Bucher

Ramon Frank

Tomas Sanchez

Jerry Wills

Monty Stuart

Mark Freund

Ramiro González

Jason Rodriguez

Frank Torres

Joani Yarbrough

Michael Cassidy

James Alan Hensz

Juddson Keith Linn

Thomas Rosales Jr.

Jeff O'Haco

Melissa Forney

Deborah Ann Piper

Cormac McCarthy

Kristin Wilkinson

Richard L. Johnson

Larry Paxton

Anne McCarthy

Traci Kirshbaum

Marty Stuart

Mary Vernieu

Jonathan Gordon

Doug Hall

Bruce Heller

Clark Hunter

Mary Ann Madden

Robert Salerno

Barry Markowitz

Max Biscoe

Edouard F. Henriques

Keith Sayer

Dean Beville

Kate Biscoe

David Bach

Lora Hirschberg

Drama

Romance

Western

All the Pretty Horses

Miramax

Columbia Pictures

United States of America

English

Español

dancing

chess

airplane

prisoner

falsely accused

coffin

texas

ranch

rifle

beating

jail

corpse

lasso

cautery

1940s

The 35% movie that maybe originally was a minor classic?

All the Pretty Horses is directed by Billy Bob Thornton and adapted from Cormac McCarthy's novel of the name name by Ted Tally. It stars Matt Damon, Penélope Cruz, Henry Thomas & Lucas Black. Marty Stuart scores the music and Barry Markowitz photographs it. Plot finds Damon as John Grady Cole, a young cowboy who travels with his best friend, Lacey Rawlings, from Texas across the border into Mexico. It's a journey that sees acquaintances come and go, love blossom and the harshness of the world become all too real to such young eyes.

A big financial disaster for Columbia Pictures and Miramax Films who lost nearly $40 million on the film. Serves them right I say, for Thornton's original cut was a long epic piece thought to be around three and a half hours in length. But good old Harvey Weinstein demanded drastic cuts to be made and Thornton had to trim it to just nearly two hours in running time. That's a lot of story gone astray, and boy does it show, no wonder Damon himself bitterly commented that to lose 35% of your movie ultimately leaves you with a completely different film. It's such a shame because although it's now a film chocked with flaws and flow problems, one can see that in its original cut there had to be at worst an involving rites-of-passage story.

So what are we left with? Well it's certainly not a donkey. It drips with period atmosphere and comes resplendent with a poetic beauty thanks to Markowitz's photography. Stuart's score too has the tone absolutely right, blending the old feel of the West with evocative arrangements for the more tender moments involving the protagonists: and there are tender moments, notably between Cole (Damon youthful but not really exuding a naivety for the age of the character) & Rawlings (Thomas effective and dominating his scenes). That the crucial relationship between Cole and Alejandra Villarreal (Cruz weak and lacking believability for the romantic strand) is barely formed can be laid at Weinstein's door. So too can the fact that a number of characters file in and out with blink and you miss them parts, sad when it's the likes of Robert Patrick and Sam Sheperd; and tragic in the case of Bruce Dern's judge; the latter of which is a crucial character in the final quarter but gets about three minutes screen time. Madness. Star of the movie is Black, who as young ruffian Blevins, manages to convey a deep sense of vulnerability. It's a critical role, one that affects the main character's lives, and thanks to Black's spirited performance we anxiously await what fate has in store for the lovable rogue.

So much good to sample, then, even if it feels like going out for a three course dinner and finding the main course is no longer available. It's hoped that one day we may get a directors cut from Thornton, only then you feel will All the Pretty Horses be revealed as a potential thoroughbred. 6/10

_**Unique, beautiful Western with excellent score, but gaping holes in the story**_

Released in 2000, "All the Pretty Horses" stars Matt Damon and Henry Thomas as two West Texas cowboys, John Grady Cole and Lacey Rawlins, who are weary of all the fenced-in land in 1949 and so head to Mexico for freer pastures. There they meet up with a foolish juvenile (Lucas Black) before coming to a huge ranch where Penelope Cruze plays the owner's daughter, Alejandra. Unfortunately, unexpected problems surface. Miriam Colon plays the girl's staunch aunt and ranch matriarch while Sam Shepard and Bruce Dern have (very) small roles.

Billy Bob Thornton directed the movie based on Cormac McCarthy's novel and the original runtime was said to be around 3 hours and 12 minutes, but was cut at the insistence of distributer Harvey Weinstein to a mere 117 minutes (!). Similar circumstances forced Marlon Brando to cut his sole directed movie, 1961's "One-Eyed Jacks," from 5 hours to half that time and it turned out to be a Western masterpiece, but "All the Pretty Horses" was cut TOO much. Even an additional 20 minutes would've helped immeasurably. 

As it is, there are gaping holes in the story. For instance, there is little build-up to Cole's love affair with Alejandra. "The Horse Whisperer" (1998), by contrast, is an excellent example of proper romantic build-up. Other questions abound: What did Alejandra experience in her life that made her brazenly risk her honor? What (specifically) was the source of her deep contempt for her aunt, who seemed to be just looking out for her? Why does Alejandra's father stay on close terms with Cole even AFTER it's discovered he (supposedly) lied to him? What led up to Rawlins' suicidal confrontation with a prison heavy and the same with Cole's deadly tassel? Also, it's subtly revealed that Cole, Rawlins and Blevins (the kid) have very different views of the world, but they're never fleshed out.

The original Director's Cut has been called a masterpiece by those who've seen it, and a release of it has been looked into, but the original composer, Daniel Lanois, steadfastly refused to license his score (which, unusually, he owns) to any release of the film. If they can't work it out, then why not just use the excellent score by Marty Stuart, which is the one used in the cut-down theatrical/DVD version?

As far as locations go, it's great to have a Western actually shot in West Texas rather than supposedly taking place in Texas, but being shot in Arizona, etc. It was equally shot in New Mexico.

Although "All the Pretty Horses" has a severely troubled post-production history, it's still worth catching DESPITE the holes in the story. It has magnificent cinematography and locations, formidable actors (Damon is perfect as the humble, respectable protagonist), a magnificent score/soundtrack, an epic tone and an unpredictable story. In short, it's a unique Western that not everyone's going to like because uniqueness polarizes opinion. It's not great simply because it was butchered in post-production, but it's still a quality film and, in many ways, a pleasure to behold.

Some criticize it as soporific and that's true in the sense that it's not a rollicking Western, like 2001's "American Outlaws," which plays like "Indiana Jones goes West." "All the Pretty Horses," by contrast, is a realistic Western drama with the tone of the aforementioned "Horse Whisperer," but with periodic actions sequences. It's a refreshing change from the typical in-your-face, loud, CGI-laden, foul-mouthed, unreal movies we have constantly rammed at us; and, again, the music's great. 

GRADE: B-

All the Pretty Horses Trailer

All the Pretty Horses( 2000)

Some passions can never be tamed.

Overview

Top Billed Cast

Social

A review by John Chard

Written by John Chard on Thu Feb 09 2017

Media

Recommendations

Facts

Status

Original Language

Budget

Revenue

Keywords