Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Paul McCloskey

   Wayne Montgomery

2. 

   Barbara Lessin

   Andrea Montgomery

3. 

   Mark Cray

   John Craven

4. 

   Michael Manfredo Jr.

   Kyle Stratten

5. 

   Mark Marcarian

   Charles Craven

6. 

   Jeremy Bishop

   Luke Crossen

7. 

   Nate Edwards

   Henry Crossen

8. 

   Bill Ushler

   Detective Michael Hanlon

9. 

   Lisa Panzer

   Marti Dobson

10. 

    Roberto Lombardi

    Detective Joe Moretti

11. 

    Jerry Ross

    Ray Olsen

12. 

    David M. Sitbon

    Grey Mortimer

13. 

    Shawn Shillingford

    Christopher Hagans

14. 

    Todd Kaylor

    Detective Paul Brewer

15. 

    Michael J. Panichelli Jr.

    Detective John Haynes

16. 

    Bruce DeSantis

    Todd Montgomery

17. 

    Emily Spiegel

    Monica Montgomery

18. 

    Cara Duncan

    Crime Scene Investigator

19. 

    James Schaeffer

    Detective David Shaw

20. 

    Jenn Phillips

    Reporter

21. 

    Fearon Derry

    Newscaster (voice)

22. 

    Benjamin P. Ablao Jr.

    Detective Chris Dolendo

23. 

    Tony J. Spadaccini

    Detective Bill Price

24. 

    Devin Kates

    Seth Hayden

25. 

    Joey Garrison

    Jared

26. 

    Brinke Stevens

    Julie Quinn

27. 

    Ruth Weisberg

    Narrator (voice)

28. 

    Daniel Eyre

    Todd Montgomery - Age 2

29. 

    Emily Eyre

    Monica Montgomery- Baby

30. 

    Florence Coia

    Rebecca Collins

31. 

    Damien Colletti

    Charles Craven Jr.

32. 

    Michael Agnew

    Joseph Barker

33. 

    Brandon Macker

    Daniel Azzurri

34. 

    John Coia

    Alan Montgomery

35. 

    Sabrina Manfredo

    Allison Stratten

36. 

    Taylor Sampere

    Austin

37. 

    Kati Jordan

    Holly Craven

38. 

    Kyle Field

    Pete (Reaction Video #1)

39. 

    Kelly Tull

    Melissa (Reaction Video #2)

40. 

    Nikki Krumm

    Sarah (Reaction Video #2)

41. 

    Robbie Sanders

    Brian (Reaction Video #3)

42. 

    Jack A. Walker

    Chip (Reaction Video #4)

43. 

    Al Holmes

    Gary (Reaction Video #5)

44. 

    June Munson

    Marti’s Assistant

45. 

    Michael Manfredo

    Detective Tony Capello

46. 

    Jennifer Griffith-Munson

    Marie Craven

47. 

    Kevin Ashley

    Chester Donnell

48. 

    Edward Kime

    Bookstore Customer

49. 

    Lucas Brown

    Bookstore Customer

50. 

    Dave Wrighteous

    Bookstore Customer

51. 

    Elizabeth Clark

    Bookstore Customer

52. 

    Allan Kleban

    Bookstore Customer

53. 

    Andrew Schwartz

    Bookstore Customer

54. 

    Michael Oreszczyn

    Bookstore Customer

55. 

    Rin Cyano

    Victim

56. 

    Amber Manfredo

    Victim

57. 

    William Ruh

    Victim

58. 

    Matt Veltri

    Victim

59. 

    Kelly Alexander

    Victim

60. 

    Bailey Heintzelman

    Victim

61. 

    Mikaela Knapp

    Victim

62. 

    Jay Cusack

    Victim

63. 

    Bill Jackson

    Victim

64. 

    Dave Wascavage

    Victim

65. 

    Stacey Lowery

    Victim

66. 

    Melissa Torrence

    Victim

67. 

    Beth Sikma

    Victim

68. 

    Erick Kneisler

    Victim

69. 

    Fran Slaczka

    Victim

70. 

    Sue Morrow

    Victim

71. 

    Karen Kennedy

    Victim

72. 

    Mary Brown

    Victim

73. 

    Glynis Sampere

    Debbie

74. 

    Lauren Gaskell

    D.B.I. Investigator

75. 

    Derek Rushlow

    Mike

76. 

    Brendan Bertolini

    Fortunato

77. 

    Eric Moyer

    Lewis