Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Seth Peterson

   Robbie Levinson

2. 

   Bruce Davison

   Pastor Boyd

3. 

   Chad Donella

   Chris Boyd

4. 

   Cindy Pickett

   Barbara McCoy

5. 

   Brian J. Smith

   Trey McCoy

6. 

   Susan Blakely

   Martha Boyd

7. 

   Lin Shaye

   Kathleen Slansky

8. 

   Farah White

   Det. Elizabeth Fisher

9. 

   Giancarlo Esposito

   Detective Esposito

10. 

    Sean Hennigan

    Jim McCoy

11. 

    Brandy Little

    Stella

12. 

    Ben Bathman

    Connor Davis

13. 

    Luke King

    Alton Kachim

14. 

    Earl Browning III

    Detective Loy

15. 

    Scarlett McAlister

    Doctor Kucera

16. 

    Connor Gewin

    4-year-old Trey

17. 

    Tyler Farris

    10-year-old Trey

18. 

    Trevor Sterling Stovall

    Fisher's Son

19. 

    Jason Hair-Wynn

    Boy in Jail (uncredited)

20. 

    Preston Strother

    Boy in Church (uncredited)

21. 

    Tyler Strother

    Boy in Church (uncredited)

22. 

    Cyrus Thompson

    Boy in the Park (uncredited)

23. 

    Tom Marcantel

    Father Tim

24. 

    Hana Kapp

    Salesperson

25. 

    Cas Dodgen

    Policeman

26. 

    Brock Cravy

    Young Man

27. 

    Kellie Rasberry

    Carla, Robbie's Coworker

28. 

    Dee Hennigan

    Daycare Teacher

29. 

    Keni LaTronico

    Robbie's Mother (as Keni la Troncio)

30. 

    Vernon Reeves

    Seth's Father

31. 

    Juan Gonzalez

    Private Investigator

32. 

    Heidie

    Phoebe

33. 

    Libby Villari

    Shirley

34. 

    Delia Rose

    Church Member (as Delia Johnson)

35. 

    Jenn Wright

    Church Officer #1

36. 

    Joe L. Blevins

    Deacon (uncredited)

37. 

    Nathan Childs

    Police Officer (uncredited)

38. 

    Phil Harrington

    Doctor on Ward (uncredited)

39. 

    Aaron Holt

    CSI Agent (uncredited)

40. 

    Christopher Holt

    Sunday School Boy (uncredited)

41. 

    Jennifer Holt

    Child on Playground (uncredited)

42. 

    Kevin Holt

    Day Care Boy (uncredited)

43. 

    Nicole Holt

    Detective / Funeral Guest (uncredited)

44. 

    Phillip Lanier

    Choir Singer (uncredited)

45. 

    Tiffany McManus

    Sunday School Kid (uncredited)

46. 

    Jimmy Paleschic

    Crime Scene Investigator (uncredited)

47. 

    Sloane Schoeneberg

    Church Member (uncredited)

48. 

    Summer Selby

    Precinct Worker (uncredited)