Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Kyle Mooney

   James Pope

2. 

   Mark Hamill

   Ted Mitchum

3. 

   Jorge Lendeborg Jr.

   Spencer

4. 

   Matt Walsh

   Greg Pope

5. 

   Michaela Watkins

   Louise Pope

6. 

   Ryan Simpkins

   Aubrey Pope

7. 

   Greg Kinnear

   Detective Vogel

8. 

   Alexa Demie

   Meredith

9. 

   Beck Bennett

   Detective Bander

10. 

    Claire Danes

    Emily

11. 

    Chance Crimin

    Logan

12. 

    Jane Adams

    April Mitchum

13. 

    Andy Samberg

    Eric

14. 

    Kate Lyn Sheil

    Arielle Smiles

15. 

    James Anthony Green

    Police Officer

16. 

    Kim Fischer

    Female Reporter

17. 

    Kelly Chapman

    News Anchor

18. 

    Nick Rutherford

    Brigsby Bear fan

19. 

    Reagan Pineda

    Reality Talking Head

20. 

    Kiera Milan Hendricks

    Young Smiles Sisters

21. 

    Tim Heidecker

    Coach Brad

22. 

    Rex Morgan

    Gordo

23. 

    Ellery Davidson

    Hannah Slice

24. 

    Christopher Sullivan

    FBI Agent

25. 

    Joseph Paul Branca

    Space Alien

26. 

    Nikolas Mikkelsen

    Theatre Patron

27. 

    Matthew P. Watts

    Prison Guard

28. 

    Ashlyn Brooke Anderson

    Wizzle Prince (uncredited)

29. 

    Yvonne D Bennett

    Party Guest (uncredited)

30. 

    Kami Christiansen

    Nurse (uncredited)

31. 

    Paul Nathan Cuthbert

    Prison Visitor (uncredited)

32. 

    Teresa Duran-Norvick

    Premiere Audience (uncredited)

33. 

    Gerry Garcia

    (uncredited)

34. 

    Angella Joy

    Reporter (uncredited)

35. 

    Marilyn Miller

    Court Reporter (uncredited)

36. 

    Chris Provost

    Prison Guard (uncredited)

37. 

    Seth Williams

    Cameraman (uncredited)

38. 

    Julio Torres

    Man Getting Haircut (uncredited)