Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Kiana Madeira

   Sarah Fier / Deena Johnson

2. 

   Ashley Zukerman

   Solomon Goode / Nick Goode

3. 

   Gillian Jacobs

   Adult Ziggy / C. Berman

4. 

   Olivia Scott Welch

   Hannah Miller / Samantha 'Sam' Fraser

5. 

   Benjamin Flores Jr.

   Henry Fier / Josh Johnson

6. 

   Darrell Britt-Gibson

   Martin P. Franklin

7. 

   Sadie Sink

   Constance / Christine 'Ziggy' Berman

8. 

   Emily Rudd

   Abigail / Cindy Berman

9. 

   McCabe Slye

   Mad Thomas / Tommy Slater

10. 

    Julia Rehwald

    Lizzie / Kate Schmidt

11. 

    Fred Hechinger

    Isaac / Simon Kalivoda

12. 

    Jordana Spiro

    The Widow / Mary Lane

13. 

    Jordyn DiNatale

    Ruby Lane

14. 

    Elizabeth Scopel

    'Real' Sarah Fier

15. 

    Randy Havens

    George Fier

16. 

    Matthew Zuk

    Elijah Goode / Mayor Will Goode

17. 

    Michael Chandler

    'The Pastor' Cyrus Miller

18. 

    Lacy Camp

    Grace Miller / Mrs. Fraser

19. 

    Jeremy Ford

    Caleb / Peter

20. 

    Patrick Roper

    Union Townsman 1

21. 

    Robert Bryan Davis

    Union Townsman 2

22. 

    Lynne Ashe

    Union Townswoman

23. 

    Charlene Amoia

    Beth Kimball / Rachel Thompson

24. 

    Mark Ashworth

    Jakob Berman

25. 

    Todd Allen Durkin

    The Watchman / Officer Kapinski

26. 

    Ryan Simpkins

    Alice

27. 

    Noah Bain Garret

    Skull Mask

28. 

    Keil Oakley Zepernick

    'Shame Killer' Isaac Milton

29. 

    Emily Brobst

    Billy Barker

30. 

    Kevin Waterman

    'The Milkman' Harry Rooker

31. 

    Ted Sutherland

    Young Nick Goode

32. 

    Lloyd Pitts

    Nightwing Killer

33. 

    Daniel Thomas May

    Officer Kuzio

34. 

    Meghan Packer

    TV Anchor

35. 

    Nilah Blasingame

    Highschool Kid

36. 

    Rachel Doman

    Queen of Air and Darkness Girl