Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Gary Cooper

   Captain Christopher Holden

2. 

   Paulette Goddard

   Abby

3. 

   Howard Da Silva

   Garth

4. 

   Boris Karloff

   Guyasuta, Chief of the Senecas

5. 

   Cecil Kellaway

   Jeremy Love

6. 

   Ward Bond

   John Fraser

7. 

   Katherine DeMille

   Hannah

8. 

   Henry Wilcoxon

   Captain Steele

9. 

   C. Aubrey Smith

   Lord Chief Justice

10. 

    Victor Varconi

    Captain Simeon Ecuyer

11. 

    Virginia Grey

    Diana

12. 

    Porter Hall

    Leach

13. 

    Mike Mazurki

    Bone

14. 

    Richard Gaines

    Colonel George Washington

15. 

    Virginia Campbell

    Mrs. John Fraser

16. 

    Gavin Muir

    Lieut. Fergus McKenzie

17. 

    Alan Napier

    Sir William Johnson

18. 

    Ninetta Sunderland

    Mrs. Pruitt

19. 

    Marc Lawrence

    Medicine Man Sioto

20. 

    Jane Nigh

    Evelyn

21. 

    Raymond Hatton

    Venango Scout

22. 

    John Mylong

    Colonel Henry Bouquet

23. 

    George Kirby

    London Astronomer Charles Mason

24. 

    Leonard Carey

    London Astronomer Jeremiah Dixon

25. 

    Frank Wilcox

    Richard Henry Lee

26. 

    Davison Clark

    Mr. Carroll of Virginia

27. 

    Griff Barnett

    Brother Andrews of Pennsylvania

28. 

    Lloyd Bridges

    Lieut. Hutchins

29. 

    Oliver Thorndike

    Lieut. Baillie

30. 

    Rus Conklin

    Mamaultee

31. 

    Iron Eyes Cody

    Red Corn

32. 

    Julia Faye

    Widow Swivens

33. 

    Paul E. Burns

    Dan McCoy

34. 

    Mary Field

    Maggie

35. 

    Diane Wadelow

    Lancashire Lass

36. 

    Clarence Muse

    Jason

37. 

    Cecil B. DeMille

    Self - Narrator (voice) (uncredited)

38. 

    Dorothy Adams

    Woman at Fort Pitt (uncredited)

39. 

    James Flavin

    Villager (uncredited)

40. 

    Francis Ford

    Frontiersman on Fort Pitt Roof (uncredited)

41. 

    Byron Foulger

    Townsman (uncredited)

42. 

    Beulah Archuletta

    Seneca Woman (uncredited)