Top Billed Cast

1. 

   Misha Collins

   Paul Bernardo

2. 

   Laura Prepon

   Karla Homolka

3. 

   Brandon Routh

   Tim

4. 

   Patrick Bauchau

   Dr. Arnold

5. 

   Emilie Jacobs

   Debbie

6. 

   Adam Lieberman

   Detective Morgan

7. 

   Shawn Hoffman

   Detective Steve Kirby

8. 

   William Duffy

   Detective Porter

9. 

   Alex Boyd

   Nick

10. 

    Cherilyn Hayres

    Tammy Homolka

11. 

    Kristen Honey

    Tina McCarthy (as Kristen Swieconek)

12. 

    Cole James

    Tina's Friend

13. 

    Carole Ita White

    Waitress

14. 

    Fiona Manners

    Rape Victim #1

15. 

    Tanya Lemelle

    Rape Victim #2

16. 

    Tony Shawkat

    Border Guard #1

17. 

    Tess Harper

    Molly

18. 

    Leonard Kelly-Young

    Dan

19. 

    Anna Pheil

    Patricia

20. 

    Zach DiLiberto

    Doug

21. 

    Nikki McCauley

    Jessie

22. 

    Sarah Foret

    Kaitlyn Ross

23. 

    Tony Denison

    Detective Burroughs

24. 

    Jeff Doucette

    Burroughs's Partner

25. 

    Bunny Gibson

    Mrs. Ross

26. 

    Bradford English

    Mr. Ross

27. 

    John Ross Clark

    Attorney Warner

28. 

    Philippe Bergeron

    Attorney Siegel

29. 

    Eileen Dietz

    Helen

30. 

    Ross Patterson

    Steve